Star
Trek Episode Archives Star
Trek Episode Archives
Media Archives:
Synopsis: The crew is baffled by the mysterious appearance of the ship's archeologist, who returns to claim her son... hours after her death. An Away Team, led by Worf, investigates a barren planet once inhabited by the Koinonians, a race which destroyed themselves in a lengthy war. While exploring an underground tunnel, archeologist Marla Aster is killed by a bomb buried years earlier beneath the surface. Worf, though injured in the blast himself, feels he is to blame for the tragedy, despite Picard's assurances that it was an accident. Lt. Aster is survived by a son, 12-year-old Jeremy. Together with Troi, Picard informs the child of his mother's tragic death. Knowing that Jeremy's father is also deceased, Troi is concerned by the child's stoic reaction to the news. Worf, himself an orphan, feels a special kinship with Jeremy and tells Troi of his wish to perform a Klingon ceremony, the R'uustai (or Bonding), with the boy. A short time later, Troi detects an alien presence on board the U.S.S. Enterprise. In his quarters, Jeremy senses a movement and turns to see what appears to be his late mother, telling him that they are both going to leave the starship and live on the planet. When Worf discovers Lt. Aster's impostor, she vanishes. She later reappears and transforms Jeremy's room into the Aster home on Earth, as the confused boy rushes to the warmth of his "mother's" arms. Determining that an energy beam from the planet is powering the image of Aster, Picard orders the crew to sever it. Undaunted, the energy field then gathers into a glowing mass, enters the ship and tries to gain control of the transporter room, while Jeremy and his mother hurry toward it to make their escape. When the alien Aster is trapped in the Enterprise's forcefield, she confesses that she is part of a lifeform that survived the Koinonian Wars. In an effort to prevent further suffering from that conflict, the being recreated Jeremy's mother and home to comfort him. Wesley, who suffered the loss of his own father, joins Picard in explaining to Jeremy that it is part of being human to mourn and feel pain, as well as joy. At first torn between his "mother" and reality, Jeremy soon decides to stay on board the U.S.S. Enterprise. After the lifeform leaves the ship, Worf performs the R'uustai with Jeremy, making them brothers forever. Timothy Lynch's Star Trek: The Next Generation Episode Reviews Review Date: 10/21/89 WARNING: The following post contains spoilers for this week's TNG episode, "The Bonding". The spoilers are given in the context of a review, and as such are probably NOT localized. Be warned. Yep. Right after this last Bleh. Yep, that's right. Bleh. While this wasn't nearly as bad as, say, "Home Soil", or, worse yet, "The Royale" (ptui!), and it was better than the previews last week made it out to be, it was not very good. More after a synopsis, which this week will be brief (for once): The Enterprise is in orbit around a planet (I've forgotten the name) which once contained a highly intelligent civilization known as the Koinonians (sp?). It seems that they destroyed themselves in a war many centuries ago, but they are of great archaeological interest. An away team is down on the planet, consisting of a bunch of random crewmen (archaeologists all), and Worf. An explosion occurs, and one crewman is killed. She has a son, 12 years old, aboard the ship. To Picard falls the sad duty of telling him his mother has died (particularly sad because his father died 5 years or so earlier). Lots of grief abounds: Worf is pissed because she died due to what he saw as his negligence, Wesley is reminded a great deal of the time ten years or so ago when Picard had to tell him that his father had been killed, and so forth. All well and good. EXCEPT, there's some "presence" on the planet below. It starts sucking power away from the ship, and uses this energy to give the kid some illusionary happiness, starting with his mother back. From here, it goes downhill. The main gist of this part is that there were two races on the planet: "one of energy, and one of matter". They didn't want the kid to be sad, so they helped him. Picard eventually convinces her/it that grief is natural, and reality is far preferable to a lifetime of illusion. (He uses Wes's reaction to his own father's death as an example, and eventually manages to get the kid (sorry, I forgot his name as well, though Jeremy sounds right) to acknowledge his grief and anger. Hoo-rah. The title of the episode comes from the "rustai", a Klingon ceremony that Worf goes through with Jeremy, to celebrate the life of one who has died. See? Short synop. Now, some comments: I had very mixed feelings while watching this episode. Now, one phrase I would use to describe this was "technically proficient". They covered the two bits of death-related continuity that were necessary: the death of Jack Crusher, and that of Tasha Yar. They mentioned everything they needed to. They had an ending that sort of made sense. They didn't do anything really WRONG. The problem is, they didn't do anything particularly RIGHT either. The only really good scene I recall is in 10-Forward. Data is confused, because he keeps getting asked how "well" he knew the crewmember who died, and he asks Riker what difference familiarity makes in death. Riker asks him about how he felt when Tasha died, as opposed to here, and Data reflects that the feelings of loss are not nearly as strong in this case. When he asks why humans do not feel the loss so keenly with all deaths, Riker remarks that "If we did, maybe human history would've been a lot less bloody". A reasonably well done scene. There was also a pretty good scene between Wes and Bev, about Jack Crusher. I actually felt the pain of their loss there, so I suppose they were doing something right. However, it was still just...there. I'm glad they focused on Wesley for this situation. That made sense. However, they did not do the one thing which would have let me forgive them for a great many other indiscretions. We got no new information about Jack's death, or even the circumstances in which Picard had to tell them. I would have very much liked a little more backround, or even, God help me, a FLASHBACK. If they'd done that, my opinion would have skyrocketed. But they didn't. It felt many times like the writers almost went through some kind of rulebook, saying, "Okay...death? Oh--gotta mention Tasha and Crusher. Okay. What now? Alien presence. Hmm...page 39." No doubt some of this feeling was brought on by the robotic acting of the mother and child, but it just felt as though no one's heart was really in this. When I said "robotic acting", I meant that. Ugh. The mother, fortunately, only had one big speech, which I found abysmally done. (Something about the Koinonians destroying themselves, and her/its race not permitting a rerun of that.) The child, I suppose, was par for the course for most 12-year-old actors, but I didn't find him very well done. (It didn't help that he looked like a cross between Boxey from "Battlestar Galactica", and a reject from "Village of the Damned", either.) Oh, almost forgot. One scene which I did like: Picard sounding off in a turbolift about children on starships. While I wish it had been more consistently done, the scene itself was fairly well played. And one final thing: I found entirely too many references to how important grief is, and how we all need to have our time of grief. I'm sorry, but it felt entirely too much like Lawrence Luckinbill was going to jump out from behind a curtain and say "Share your pain with me", and once was a great deal more than enough for that, thank you. Well, that's as may be. I'll just give some ratings now and wait for next week. Plot: 4. The kid coping with his mother's death got a 7, but the "alien presence" bit brought this way down. Plot Handling: 6. As I said, "technically proficient", but no more. Characterization: 6. Might've been a 7, but for the guests' acting. Technical: 8. A couple of beautiful tactical shots, a la Geordi. TOTAL: 24/4===> 6. Highly mediocre. Better luck next time. NEXT WEEK: The Enterprise is having engine problems again, it seems. This time, though, they're in an asteroid field, which could be a lot of fun. Bye now.
Tim Lynch (Cornell's first Astronomy Major) "Captain Pike has illusion, and you have reality. May you find your way as pleasant." --The way to do an illusion/reality episode RIGHT. Copyright 1994, Timothy W. Lynch. All rights reserved, but feel free to ask. This article is explicitly prohibited from being used in any off-net compilation without due attribution and *express written consent of the author*. Walnut Creek and other CD-ROM distributors, take note. Related
Links: Cast:
Patrick Stewart as Jean-Luc Picard™ Guest Cast:
Colm Meaney as O'Brien Creative staff:
Director: Winrich Kolbe |
